What Happened
The carriers contended that the FCC’s enforcement process deprived them of a constitutional safeguard guaranteed in civil cases involving substantial financial penalties. Under the FCC framework, companies can pay a fine and seek review through the federal appeals courts rather than having the case initially decided by a jury. AT&T and Verizon argued this bypassed their right to a jury trial.
According to the Court, the carriers could have refused to pay the fines and forced the government to pursue collection efforts, a process that ultimately could have resulted in a jury trial. Chief Justice Roberts wrote, “The FCC’s forfeiture proceedings fit comfortably within” the Supreme Court’s Seventh Amendment precedents, adding, “And the orders did not reflect the ultimate determination of any fact because, before the carriers could have been made to pay, the Government was required to prove its case to a jury.”
The Reaction
Justice Clarence Thomas was the lone dissenter. The outcome was foreshadowed during oral arguments, where several justices appeared unconvinced by AT&T‘s and Verizon‘s constitutional objections and suggested that FCC penalty orders do not become legally binding until a court is asked to enforce them. Justice Kavanaugh told the attorney representing the carriers, “It seems like you’ve won on the law going forward, one way or the other,” according to ARSTechnica.
Andrew Bergmayer said in a press release, “The Supreme Court got this one right. AT&T and Verizon sold access to their customers’ location data, then failed to stop bounty hunters and even a rogue sheriff from using it to track people who had no idea they were being followed.”
What This Means
The ruling strengthens the federal government’s power to impose administrative penalties on companies accused of breaking telecommunications and privacy laws, while reducing a constitutional challenge that could have greatly restricted the enforcement powers of regulatory agencies. It is a major victory for federal regulators seeking to police privacy violations in the telecommunications industry. The decision affirms that the FCC’s penalty orders are not self-executing and remain nonbinding absent a jury trial, allowing the agency to continue its enforcement framework without requiring jury involvement at the initial penalty stage.