SCOTUS Rules Against AT&T, Verizon Over Fines For Selling Location Data –

The Supreme Court ruled Tuesday against AT&T and Verizon in a closely watched dispute over federal penalties tied to the sale of consumers’ real-time location data, preserving the FCC’s authority to impose financial penalties through its administrative enforcement system.The dispute stemmed from $104 million in FCC fines imposed on AT&T and Verizon in 2024 over allegations that the companies improperly handled customers’ real-time location data, conduct first brought to light in 2018. The case reached the Supreme Court after a split among federal appeals courts, with AT&T persuading the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to throw out an FCC fine, while Verizon lost a similar challenge before the 2nd Circuit.

What Happened

The carriers contended that the FCC’s enforcement process deprived them of a constitutional safeguard guaranteed in civil cases involving substantial financial penalties. Under the FCC framework, companies can pay a fine and seek review through the federal appeals courts rather than having the case initially decided by a jury. AT&T and Verizon argued this bypassed their right to a jury trial.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *